The missing dimension

El Capitan and Fresh Snow, Yosemite

El Capitan and Fresh Snow, Yosemite

*   *   *   *

It seems too obvious to mention, but I’ll say it anyway: Photography is a futile attempt to render a three-dimensional world through a two-dimensional medium. Unfortunately, that reality doesn’t seem to keep people from putting their eye to their viewfinder and clicking without regard for their camera’s vision. But here’s a secret: While anyone with a camera can manage the lateral (left-to-right) aspect of a scene, the photographers who separate themselves are those able to convey the illusion of depth by translating a scene’s actual depth to their camera’s virtual depth.

Creating the illusion of depth isn’t rocket science. It starts with seeking a foreground for your beautiful background, or a background for your beautiful foreground. Once you’ve figured out your foreground/background, do your best to ensure that the elements at varying depths don’t merge with each other—the more elements in your frame stand alone, the more you invite your viewers to move incrementally through the frame, hopping (subconsciously), front to back, from one visual point to the next. Getting elements to stand apart often requires some physical effort on your part (sorry). Moving left/right, up/down, foreword/backward changes the relationship between objects at varying depths, sometimes quite significantly.

With your foreground and background identified, decide whether you want the entire image in focus, or selective focus that guides your viewer to a particular point in the frame. With all your pieces in place, you’re ready to choose your f-stop and focus point.

For example

The Merced River at Valley View is a minefield of jutting rocks and branches. The above image took at least five minutes before everything was lined up to my satisfaction. Relative to the distant El Capitan, the close foreground changed significantly as I shifted position. After surveying the possibilities from a distance, I decided I wanted to be as close to the river as possible, with my tripod at its maximum height, to capture as much reflection as possible. With my camera off the tripod, I moved around on the slippery rocks at the river’s edge (easier said than done), framing shots of varying focal lengths until I had something pretty close to what I wanted. Next I brought over my tripod, affixed my camera, and made micro refinements until I was satisfied with the composition.

In this scene I wanted maximum sharpness throughout the frame. The closest rocks were about eight feet away; with the help of the depth of field app on my iPhone, I determined that at 35mm and f11 (my lens’s sharpest f-stop), I could focus about twelve feet from my camera and be sharp from six feet to infinity. Selecting a rock about twelve feet away, I switched to live-view, selected the rock, magnified the view ten times, and manually focused.

I dialed my polarizer to a point that balanced the El Capitan reflection (which I wanted) with the foreground glare (which I didn’t want) as much as possible (always a subjective exercise in compromise). To determine my exposure, I spot-metered on a bright cloud (live-view is off now) and dialed my shutter speed until the meter indicated +2.


22 Comments on “The missing dimension

  1. Gee, Mr. Hart, that’s a really nice picture. You must have a really good camera.
    :-)) OK…be honest….your blood pressure is how high right now?
    Honestly, thanks for sharing your pre-exposure workflow. And yes, the result is stunning.

  2. Great photo.

    And thank you for also documenting the work that went into making it.

  3. Gary. if I ever make the time for a workshop,it will be with one that you give for the simple reason-you are straight forward with fellow photographers in expressing what is needed to reach higher levels in this art.Your love and talent for this medium is obvious and you will attract many aspiring artist that appreciate your leadership… thanks, mm

  4. Pingback: Things You’ll Find Interesting December 3, 2012 | Chuq Von Rospach, Photographer and Author

  5. Awesome picture, Gary and thanks for the instruction, especially about the metering. Too often I compose in Aperture Priority and accept the metering as correct.

    Did you use a fixed focal length or zoom lens?

    Look forward to trying something like this in the Wildflowers workshop next April and hope to get half as great a shot.


  6. Loved the image Gary and the details to pull it off. What is the name of your favorite DOF app?

    • Thanks, Jim. I use Depth of Field Calculator by Essence Computing. I haven’t really tried any of the others out there, but this one does the job for me.

  7. Pingback: A perfect end to a perfect day « Eloquent Nature by Gary Hart

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: