It’s Not an Etch a Sketch

Gary Hart Photography: Grand Morning, Yavapai Point, Grand Canyon

Grand Morning, Yavapai Point, Grand Canyon
Sony a6300
Sony/Zeiss 16-35 f4
.6 seconds
ISO 200

Who remembers the Etch A Sketch? For those who didn’t have a childhood, an Etch A Sketch is a mechanical drawing device that’s erased by turning it upside-down and shaking vigorously. 

One of the great misconceptions among photographers (and who isn’t a photographer these days?) is that the tripod’s sole value is to eliminate camera shake. I bring this up because I frequently hear photographers brag that they rarely use a tripod anymore because image stabilization is so good—and anyway, even when stabilization won’t be enough to prevent camera shake, they can just increase the ISO.

But before you throw out your tripod, consider that digital capture has given it a new lease on life. Unlike film cameras, a digital camera gives lets us instantly review each image to check the composition, exposure, and sharpness. Photographing on a tripod, when I find something that requires fixing, rather than attempting to recreate the shot, I can refine the composition I just evaluated. Let me explain.

When I come across a scene that I deem photo-worthy, I treat my first click like a rough draft, the first step toward the final image. I stand back with my capture displayed on my LCD, critique my effort, refine it, then click again. I repeat this process until I’m satisfied. In other words, each frame becomes an improvement of the preceding frame.

Taking this approach without a tripod, I feel like I’m erasing an Etch A Sketch after each click. That’s because after each click, I have to drop the camera from my eye and extend it in front of me to review the image, essentially wiping clean my previous composition. Before I can make the inevitable adjustments to my most recent capture, I must return the camera to my eye and completely recreate the composition I just evaluated.

Before I continue, let me just acknowledge that there are indeed many valid reasons to not use a tripod. For example, you get a tripod pass if your subject is in motion (sports, wildlife, kids, etc.), you photograph events or in venues that don’t allow tripods, you have physical challenges prevent you from carrying a tripod, or even if you just plain don’t want to (first and foremost, photography has to make you happy!). But if you’re a landscape shooter who wants the best possible images, Because now I can get a sharp enough image hand-holding” is not a valid reason for jettisoning the tripod.

For example

A few years ago I was at the Grand Canyon, looking for a scene to try out my new (just released) Sony a6300 camera. My first morning started at Mather Point about 45 minutes before sunrise, but as I often do at Mather, I took the trail along the rim to Yavapai Point (about a mile), ending up at a tree I’d been eyeing for years.

On all previous attempts at this tree, something had foiled me: either the light was wrong, the sky was boring, or there were too many people. One sunrise a few years prior, I found the tree and canyon bathed in beautiful warm light, and the sky filled with dramatic, billowing clouds—perfect, except for the young couple dangling their legs over the edge and making goo-goo eyes beneath “my” tree. They looked so content, I just didn’t have the heart to shove them over the edge (I know, I know, you don’t have to say it—I’m a saint).

But this morning, everything finally aligned for me: nice clouds, beautiful sunrise color, and not a soul in sight. I went to work immediately, trying compositions, evaluating, refining—well, you know the drill. As I worked, I started honing in on the proper balance of foreground and sky, alignment of the tree with the background, depth of field, focus point, framing—I was in the zone.

When I thought I had everything exactly right, I stood back for a final critique and realized I’d missed one thing: The tree intersected the horizon. While not a deal-breaker, it’s something I try to avoid whenever possible. To fix the problem, my camera needed to be about eight inches higher. I made the small refinement, so when the color reached its crescendo a few minutes later, my composition was ready.

Raising the camera would have been no simple task if I’d been hand-holding, but (since my Really Right Stuff TVC-24L tripod, with head and camera, elevates to about six inches above my head) it was no problem with my tripod. But the extra tripod height was just a bonus. The true moral of this story, the thing that so perfectly illustrates the tripod’s value, is that there is no way I’d have gotten all the moving parts just right with a hand-held point-and-click approach.

Of course your results may vary, and as I say, photography must must make you happy. So if using a tripod truly saps the joy from your photography, by all means leave it home (and enjoy your $3,000 Etch A Sketch). But if your photography pleasure comes from getting the absolute best possible images, the tripod is your friend.

A Grand Canyon Gallery

Click an image for a closer look, and to view a slide show.

11 Comments on “It’s Not an Etch a Sketch

  1. Beautiful frame as always. I don’t understand people’s resistance to a tripod. I hollowed mine for 10 miles the other day. It’s like you’re a surgeon and don’t want to use the scissors or another tool of the trade. I love mine and use it often for landscape. There’s no other way to get good DOF and as you said, reframe with precision.

    • Thank you, Alessandra. Yeah, I don’t understand either, except that we’re all drawn to photography for different reasons, and for some lugging a tripod robs the joy and they’re willing to settle for something a little less than… 🤷🏻‍♂️

  2. Gary Wonderful image and a good story to go with it. Mark Mark Leibowitz (858) 792-6938 (O)

  3. Your explanations are always spot on, Gary. And your example of another good reason for using a tripod is excellent. Love your images as always and I’m glad you didn’t let the tree break the horizon. 😉

  4. Gary, as usual a National Geo quality photo for your opening email. Even after your encouragement in your workshops I’ve been on, I don’t use a tripod nearly as much as I should. Maybe I’ll attribute it to 1) laziness and 2) old age. When I think back at all of the camera gear I lugged around 10-15 years ago hiking at Lake Tahoe, I don’t know how I did it. I’ve kept up with and have the latest Canon gear but a couple of years ago I bought my wife and I a Sony RX100 VI for a trip to San Miguel de Allende Mexico and it was a welcomed switch. Take care.

  5. Hey Gary, beautiful shot of course. When I opened the blog my first thought was; “hey, I tried to get that very shot once when I was on your N. AZ workshop, but here was a couple there with their legs dangling over the edge and after realizing they weren’t going anywhere anytime soon I walked away looking for something else to shoot…” Too similar to be a coincidence?!

  6. Gary, I have been following your blogs and posts for years. I’m eternally thankful for these and other photographs. Take care.

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: