Dialing it in


Gary Hart Photography, Rocks and Reflection, Valley View, Yosemite

Rocks and Reflection, Valley View, Yosemite
Sony a7R
16 mm
1/3 second
ISO 200

I’m a big fan of the polarizer, so much so that each of my lenses wears a polarizer that never comes off in daylight. A couple of years ago “Outdoor Photographer” magazine published my article on using a polarizer, a slightly modified version of a blog post that appears in the Photo Tips section of this blog.

If you read that article, or pay much attention to what I write here, you know that while a polarizer can really crank up the blue in your sky, I’m not generally a fan of what the polarizer does to the sky. I find blue sky boring—making it more blue just distracts from my primary subject. And worse still, because polarization varies with the angle of view (maximum polarization occurs when composing perpendicular to the sunlight’s direction, minimum when you’re parallel to the sunlight), wide shots (in particular) display “differential polarization” that manifests as unnatural sky-color variation across the frame.

Where I find a polarizer most indispensable is terrestrial reflections. With a simple twist of a polarizer, a mirror reflection on still water is magically erased to reveal submerged rocks and leaves. More than the reflections we see on still water, a properly oriented polarizer removes distracting, color-robbing glare that jumps off of rocks and foliage. And you don’t need direct sunlight to enjoy a polarizer’s benefits—because reflections and glare exist in overcast and full shade conditions, a polarizer can significantly enhance those images as well.

But back to this differential polarization thing. As most know, a polarizer isn’t a filter that you simply slap on a lens and forget about. A rotates in its frame, changing the amount of polarization on the way—if you’re not orienting (rotating) your polarizer with each composition, you’re better off keeping it in your bag. Watching through your viewfinder as you rotate, you’ll see the scene darken and brighten—maximum polarization occurs when the scene is darkest. These changes may appear subtle at first, and in some cases will be barely visible, but the more you train your eye, the easier it becomes to detect even the most subtle polarization.

Since polarization varies with the angle of view, and any image encompasses a broad angle of view, the amount of polarization you see in any given image varies. While differential polarization is a real pain in images with a uniform surface (like a blue sky), understanding that a polarizer isn’t an all or nothing tool allows you to dial the reflection up in some parts of the scene, and down in others. Rather than automatically dialing the polarizer until the scene darkens (maximum polarization), or until the reflection pops out (minimum polarization), turn the polarizer slowly and watch the reflection advance and retreat as you turn.

That’s exactly what I did with the above image from last week’s Yosemite trip. The sunlit vestiges of a day-long rain swirled above Valley View and reflected in the drought-starved Merced River (one storm does not a drought break). Here I opted for a wide, vertical composition that left room for both foreground and sky tightly framed by El Capitan on the left and Cathedral Rocks and Bridalveil Fall on the right.

Faced with a crisp reflection and a submerged jigsaw of river-worn granite, I refused to choose one or the other. Instead, I composed my scene with a group of exposed rocks to anchor my immediate foreground, then carefully dialed away enough reflection to reveal the rounded rocks, while saving the portion of the reflection that duplicated the Yosemite icons.


I use Singh-Ray filters (polarizers and graduated neutral density)

A selective polarization gallery

Click an image for a closer look, and to enjoy the slide show

15 Comments on “Dialing it in

  1. For me, One look at any of your images – especially the ones on display here – remind me that Nobody does polarizer practice / theory / utilization any better. And your article is such a great tool. I printed it (Hope you don’t mind) and now have it not only in my Mac Book Air, but also in my camera bag and desk at work….Just a beautiful image with the new Sony – glad you are lovin’ it 😉 Great Article, Gary!!

  2. Beautiful photo Gary! Because of your guidance, I too have Polarizers for my landscape lenses. Now a tip for us unfortunate Nikon shooters who love the 14-24 f2.8 lens (the one with the bulbous nose that won’t allow for a filter). I just purchase a Fotodiox adapter that allows me to use their 145mm circular polarizer. It’s big, but I now have a polarizer and lens protection for my favorite landscape lens!!

  3. Another excellent tip (as usual). Do you use circular or linear polarizers?

    • Thanks, Allen. Circular—you don’t want to use a linear polarizer with an autofocus DSLR. I haven’t really thought hard about this (until this very minute), but a linear polarizer would probably work on a mirrorless camera (or a DSLR using live-view autofocus).

      • The original autofocus systems couldn’t handle linearly polarized light, and out of habit I have continued to buy the more expensive and thicker filters that convert the linearly polarized component we select from the incident light to circularly polarized for the focus system. Enough theory, I’ll take my Canon 7D and Fuji 100s to a camera store and try out a linear filter. I’ll let you know the results from this small sample.

    • BTW, Allen, as you may know but many don’t, the “circular” designation has nothing to do with the shape of the filter—circular describes the light it’s designed to polarize. In other words, both circular and linear polarizers can be round or rectangular.

  4. Excellent point Gary on dialing in the polarizer for neither max or min with reflections of water! There’s a balance that needs to be found.

  5. Pingback: Building a scene | Eloquent Nature by Gary Hart

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: